The Disappearing American Dream
UCR public policy expert Stan Oklobdzija explains why the prospect of home ownership in the U.S. is more elusive than ever
By David Danelski
F or generations of Americans, buying a home has been a cornerstone of financial security and a way to build wealth. But today, homeownership is increasingly out of reach, particularly for younger adults.
Home prices have risen much faster than incomes over the past several decades, while a persistent shortage of housing has pushed prices even higher in many of the nation’s most economically productive regions. More recent higher borrowing costs — mortgage interest rates over 7% — have made the problem worse. The squeeze is especially severe in California.
Here, Stan Oklobdzija, a UCR assistant professor of public policy, shares his expertise in state and local politics and housing policy to help explain what drove housing costs so far beyond reach for many Americans. He also weighs in on why California’s affordability crisis is especially acute, and what it would take to make homeownership attainable for more people.
Why is it so much harder for young adults today to buy their first home than it was for people at the same stage of life in the 1990s?
The age of the typical first-time American homebuyer has gone up by about a decade between the 1980s and today. Back then, the average age for buying a first home was 29, whereas now it’s 40, according to the National Association of Realtors. It’s not the case that young people are poorer than their parents were at that age. On average, they have similar levels of wealth, though growing inequality means that the richest millennials are wealthier while the poorest are much worse off, according to recent research in the American Journal of Sociology.
The issue is that housing is relatively less affordable today than it was during the 1970s through 1990s, save for a period of high inflation from about 1980 to 1985. That unaffordability is exacerbated in California, which didn’t used to be as expensive as it is today relative to the rest of the United States. In 1970, the median home price in California was just slightly more expensive than the national average. In 2022, it was nearly 2.5 times higher, according to U.S. Census Bureau data crunched by CalMatters.
The biggest driver of housing costs is scarcity, which is itself driven by land use laws that restrict dense housing in the most economically productive parts of the country. Twenty-three metro areas, home to about 40% of the U.S. population, produce half of the country’s GDP, according to 2023 data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. In other words, these 23 cities create as much wealth as the entire rest of the country. As such, demand to live in these dynamic regions is high. At the same time, many of these regions have made it impossible to add more housing by effectively prohibiting apartments, townhomes, or any other type of housing besides detached single-family homes. Like any other good, when housing is scarce, prices go up.
California’s housing affordability problem is particularly severe. Why have home prices here become so disconnected from what many working households can afford?
California’s problem is that it chose to have a housing crisis. Land use policy is set by local jurisdiction, each with the incentive to free-ride off urban amenities and economies without building its fair share of housing. Exacerbating the problem in California is Proposition 13, the 1978 ballot initiative that drastically curtailed how much a city can expect to gain in property tax revenues. Cities have extremely little financial incentive to build new housing and plenty of electoral incentives not to.
Of course, the state government could have stepped in decades ago to solve these coordination problems but chose not to. It wasn’t until extremely recently that state officials began aggressively wrestling land use control away from cities and counties to create uniform statewide standards. While these changes have been extremely positive, they do not go far enough. Especially today, the cost of building new housing has skyrocketed due to the Trump administration’s tariffs raising material costs. As such, many projects that would have made financial sense to build just two or three years ago do not pencil out today.
How much of California’s affordability problem is caused by not building enough housing? What roles have zoning, local governments, and opposition from existing homeowners played in limiting the housing supply?
Again, California chose and is continuing to choose its housing crisis. If the political will existed, California could be building as many new homes as Texas or other Sunbelt states. These new homes would, of course, not be the detached single-family homes on undeveloped land that are popping up in metro regions such as Houston, Atlanta, and Charlotte. But these new condominiums and apartments would address the pent-up demand that is driving home prices in coastal California through the roof.
Single-family zoning was invented in Berkeley, my hometown, as a way to institute segregation without explicitly labeling it as such. The key insight, which still holds to this day, is that by limiting the number of homes that can be built on a given lot, you can drive up the cost of each home by not allowing several households to split the cost of expensive, urban land. Limiting density still has this effect of segregating Californians by how much they can afford to pay.
Are we creating a growing economic divide between people who bought homes early enough to benefit from decades of rising values and younger people who are locked out of that wealth-building opportunity? What could that mean for younger generations over the long term?
California’s restrictionist housing policies are creating a semi-feudal state where about 18% of all property transfers made in 2025 were inheritances, according to The Wall Street Journal; this is nearly double what it is nationally. It’s hardly any wonder why about 65% of the people who left California in 2022 were people under 40, according to census data analyzed by Business Insider. This exodus of young people has dramatic consequences for the state, both in terms of cratering school enrollments and congressional apportionments, in which California is slated to lose as many as four to five seats following the 2030 census.
This also has tremendous consequences for racial inequality. Racially restrictive covenants were only made unenforceable in 1948, and further discriminatory practices persisted until after the Fair Housing Act was passed in 1968. As a result, homeownership rates among African Americans are far below that of other races because they lack the generational wealth that can be built through homeownership.
What would California have to do to make homeownership realistically attainable for more young adults? Are there policies that could make a meaningful difference, and how long might it take before buyers actually feel the effects?
The good news about California’s housing crisis being a choice is that the state can simply choose to stop having a crisis whenever it feels like doing so. The first step is to consolidate as much land use authority as possible at the state level, rather than leaving it up to cities. Demand for housing is regional and, as such, land use policy should consider the needs of an entire metropolitan area. More density, especially near existing mass transit and job centers, is essential to adding slack to our housing inventory and bringing prices down.
Next, the state has to intervene and make the actual business of building new homes more predictable. Cities vary drastically in the time they take to issue permits, both for reasons of internal capacity and resistance to new construction. Creating a uniform set of rules and predictable review times is essential to bringing down the uncertainty in the construction process, which adds tremendously to cost.
Finally, the state needs to explore reforms to bring down the cost of housing production by looking for more efficient ways of utilizing scarce land and manufacturing homes. Single-stair designs, smaller elevators, and modular construction can all drastically reduce the cost of new homes, which both lowers prices for consumers and facilitates more construction.
New construction can help bring prices down even in the short term. Both Austin and Portland have seen rents fall after a wave of new home construction in just the last 10 years. However, the state will likely need to continue this construction boom for many years to make up the deficit created by decades of restrictiveness. As such, it will need to explore ways to involve the government in housing production, such as social housing programs, in order to continue growing supply even during economic downturns — which, incidentally, is when the cost of building new homes is lowest.